The Argument

written by


« Reload image

On the way to the village store 
I drive through a down-draft 
from the neighbor’s chimney. 
Woodsmoke tumbles from the eaves 
backlit by sun, reminding me
of the fire and sulfur of Grandmother’s 
vengeful God, the one who disapproves
of jeans and shorts for girls,
dancing, strong waters, and adultery.

A moment later the smoke enters
the car, although the windows are tight, 
insinuating that I might, like Judas,
and the foolish virgins, and the rich
young man, have been made for unquenchable 
fire. God will need something to burn
if the fire is to be unquenchable.

“All things work together for the good 
for those who love God,” she said
to comfort me at Uncle Hazen’s funeral, 
where Father held me up to see
the maroon gladiolus that trembled
as we approached the bier, the elaborate 
shirred satin, brass fittings, anything,

oh, anything but Uncle’s squelched 
and made-up face.
“No! NO! How is it good to be dead?”
I cried afterward, wild-eyed and flushed. 
“God’s ways are not our ways,”
she said then out of pity
and the wish to forestall the argument.

© Jane Kenyon