Miss Edith's Modest Request

written by


« Reload image

My Papa knows you, and he says you're a man who makes reading for
  books;
But I never read nothing you wrote, nor did Papa,--I know by his
  looks.
So I guess you're like me when I talk, and I talk, and I talk all
  the day,
And they only say, "Do stop that child!" or, "Nurse, take Miss Edith
  away."

But Papa said if I was good I could ask you--alone by myself--
If you wouldn't write me a book like that little one up on the shelf.
I don't mean the pictures, of course, for to make THEM you've got to
  be smart
But the reading that runs all around them, you know,--just the
  easiest part.

You needn't mind what it's about, for no one will see it but me,
And Jane,--that's my nurse,--and John,--he's the coachman,--just
  only us three.
You're to write of a bad little girl, that was wicked and bold and
  all that;
And then you're to write, if you please, something good--very good--
  of a cat!

This cat, she was virtuous and meek, and kind to her parents, and
  mild,
And careful and neat in her ways, though her mistress was such a bad
  child;
And hours she would sit and would gaze when her mistress--that's me--
  was so bad,
And blink, just as if she would say, "Oh, Edith! you make my heart
  sad."

And yet, you would scarcely believe it, that beautiful, angelic cat
Was blamed by the servants for stealing whatever, they said, she'd
  get at.
And when John drank my milk,--don't you tell me!  I know just the
  way it was done,--
They said 'twas the cat,--and she sitting and washing her face in
  the sun!

And then there was Dick, my canary.  When I left its cage open one
  day,
They all made believe that she ate it, though I know that the bird
  flew away.
And why?  Just because she was playing with a feather she found on
  the floor.
As if cats couldn't play with a feather without people thinking
  'twas more!

Why, once we were romping together, when I knocked down a vase from
  the shelf,
That cat was as grieved and distressed as if she had done it herself;
And she walked away sadly and hid herself, and never came out until
  tea,--
So they say, for they sent ME to bed, and she never came even to me.

No matter whatever happened, it was laid at the door of that cat.
Why, once when I tore my apron,--she was wrapped in it, and I called
  "Rat!"--
Why, they blamed that on HER.  I shall never--no, not to my dying
  day--
Forget the pained look that she gave me when they slapped ME and
  took me away.

Of course, you know just what comes next, when a child is as lovely
  as that:
She wasted quite slowly away; it was goodness was killing that cat.
I know it was nothing she ate, for her taste was exceedingly nice;
But they said she stole Bobby's ice cream, and caught a bad cold
  from the ice.

And you'll promise to make me a book like that little one up on the
  shelf,
And you'll call her "Naomi," because it's a name that she just gave
  herself;
For she'd scratch at my door in the morning, and whenever I'd call
  out, "Who's there?"
She would answer, "Naomi! Naomi!" like a Christian, I vow and declare.

And you'll put me and her in a book.  And mind, you're to say I was
  bad;
And I might have been badder than that but for the example I had.
And you'll say that she was a Maltese, and--what's that you asked?
  "Is she dead?"
Why, please, sir, THERE AIN'T ANY CAT!  You're to make one up out of
  your head!

© Francis Bret Harte